Skip to content
Stalking, state by state: same behavior, different law

Stalking, state by state: same behavior, different law

Introduction

An employee comes to HR and says someone keeps contacting them. The person has followed them, shown up at their office, maybe tracked where they go. They're scared, and they want to know what their employer can do.

Most HR teams know they need to act. Fewer could say, on the spot, which legal definition of stalking applies to that employee, or whether that definition even decides the protections the employee can claim.

It matters more than you'd think. The behavior usually looks familiar: repeated unwanted contact, following, monitoring, intimidating messages. But states don't agree on what turns that behavior into a crime. And the definition that decides whether a crime happened isn't always the one that decides what an employer owes the employee.

Here's how four states handle it.

How four states define stalking

1. New York: the kind of harm changes the rules.

New York's fourth-degree stalking law (Penal Law § 120.45) starts with a course of conduct aimed at a specific person, with no legitimate purpose. The person doing it knows, or should reasonably know, that it's likely to cause reasonable fear of material harm to the other person's physical health, safety or property.

When the harm is to someone's mental or emotional health, the bar moves. The conduct has to involve following, phoning or initiating contact, and the person must already have been clearly told to stop.

A separate provision covers conduct at someone's workplace or business that's likely to make them reasonably fear for their job, business or career. That one also requires a prior warning to stop.

So in New York, what counts as stalking depends partly on what was done and what kind of harm it caused.

2. Florida: emotional distress is enough.

Florida (Statutes § 784.048) defines stalking as willfully, maliciously and repeatedly following, harassing or cyberstalking another person.

Harassment here means a course of conduct aimed at a specific person that causes substantial emotional distress and serves no legitimate purpose. No threat is needed.

Florida also names cyberstalking outright. That includes certain electronic communications and getting into someone's online accounts or internet-connected home systems without permission.

A credible threat matters only for aggravated stalking. The basic offense doesn't require one.

3. Texas: a pattern, not a single incident.

Texas (Penal Code § 42.072) requires the conduct to happen on more than one occasion, as part of the same scheme or course of conduct aimed at a specific person.

The conduct also has to meet certain conditions. It may qualify, for example, if it counts as harassment under Texas law, or if the person doing it knows or reasonably should know the victim will see it as threatening. The law also looks at the fear or distress felt by the victim and certain people close to them.

In other words, Texas weighs both what was done and what it did to the person on the receiving end.

4. California: the threat is part of the crime.

California (Penal Code § 646.9) defines stalking as willfully and maliciously following or harassing someone and making a credible threat meant to put them in reasonable fear for their safety or their immediate family's safety.

A course of conduct means two or more acts over a period of time, however short, that show a continuity of purpose.

Compare that with Florida. In California, a credible threat is a required element of criminal stalking. In Florida, it's what raises the charge to aggravated stalking.

One state, two definitions

State lines are only part of the story. Inside a single state, the definition that makes something a crime can differ from the one that decides whether an employee gets workplace protections.

New York shows how.

Under Executive Law § 296(22), New York employers must give reasonable accommodations to employees who are victims of domestic violence, so they can take time off to get medical care, reach support services, attend counseling, do safety planning or get legal help.

But who counts as a "victim of domestic violence"? The Executive Law (§ 292(34)) points to a definition in the Social Services Law (§ 459-a). That definition does include stalking. It also requires two more things: the conduct caused actual physical or emotional injury, or created a substantial risk of it, and it was committed (or allegedly committed) by a family or household member.

Family or household members include spouses, former spouses, relatives, certain people who live or have lived together, and current or former intimate partners. Casual acquaintances and ordinary business or social relationships don't count as intimate relationships.

So an employee being stalked by a coworker, a customer or someone they barely know may not qualify for this particular protection, even if the behavior could meet New York's criminal definition of stalking.

Whether something is a crime and whether an employee qualifies for a workplace protection are two separate questions, answered by two separate definitions.

What HR and corporate leaders should be asking

If you have employees in more than one state, a stalking report raises several questions at once.

  1. Jurisdiction. Which state's laws apply to this employee and what they're reporting?
  2. Classification. Does the conduct meet that state's definition of stalking, harassment or another prohibited behavior?
  3. Employment protections. Does the employee qualify for state-specific leave, reasonable accommodations or other workplace protections?
  4. Workplace safety. What should the organization do about the safety concerns, including unwanted contact at work?
  5. Confidentiality. How should sensitive information be handled while HR responds?

Keep one more thing in mind. Criminal law and employment law exist for different reasons. An employee shouldn't have to prove someone committed a crime before HR takes their safety seriously or checks which protections apply.

A general policy won't cover this. HR teams need to know the jurisdiction, the employee's situation and the specific obligations that follow from both.

Conclusion: one workplace issue, many legal meanings

Stalking is one example of how a single workplace issue can mean different things depending on where an employee lives or works.

New York, Florida, Texas and California each define the crime differently. Even within one state, the criminal definition may not match the one that unlocks employment protections.

For HR and corporate leaders, caring about the employee is the easy part. Knowing which rules apply when that employee needs help is the hard part.

And stalking is just one of thousands of differences across state and local laws. Getting workplace rights right means looking past a general policy or a single national standard to the specific protections and obligations in each jurisdiction.

This article is for general information only and isn't legal advice. Laws change; check the current statute or consult counsel before acting.